A Just Us
Falling Through the Trap
Episode 7: #10 John F. Barthelman
0:00
-1:06:42

Episode 7: #10 John F. Barthelman

Marriage, Murder, and Mania: A "Love" Story

What happens when you’re provoked? Do you have a moment of temporary insanity? And, therefore, excused from any responsibility? What if it’s your former spouse who “provoked” you? Well, John was apparently having such a moment—the same moment he happened to have a gun. This case was likely the first in the Los Angeles courts (if not all of California), to debate the temporary insanity (in a heat of passion) plea. It was a certainly a novel defense in the mid-1890s and for those packing courtroom, the topic of mental illness turned the case from a tragedy to a comedy.

#10 John Barthelman, executed May 12, 1898
Los Angeles Herald, March 31, 1897
Los Angeles Herald, November 11, 1896
Preliminary Hearing Transcript; California State University, Northridge; University Library
1894 Los Angeles Sanborn Fire Maps, Library of Congress, Digital Collection
Google Maps, current
Dr. Rebecca Lee Dorsey, pictured with her niece whom she adopted; source: Wikipedia
1898; source: Center for Sacramento History

YOUTUBE (more photos)
INSTAGRAM
PATREON

Links:
William Radam’s Microbe Killer

Source: Museum of Health Care, at Kingston, Research Collection Catalogue

ABOUT THIS PODCAST: Step behind the walls of Folsom Prison where author and criminal justice professional, April Moore, delves into the haunting, yet profoundly human stories of the 93 men executed between 1895 and 1937. Join us as we explore the paradoxes of justice, taking a deeper look at the death penalty, and re-humanizing those that history might have left behind. New episode every 3rd Friday of the month. Episode extras and bonus episodes available on Patreon!

Music:

Intro: “Lamentation,” by Wastelander
“St. Mary,” by Chelsea McGough and Stephen Keech
“As I Dream,” by Moments
“Not As They Seem,” by Wicked Cinema
“Our Web of Lies,” by Moments
“Cat and Mouse,” by Wicked Cinema
“I Will Never Forget You,” by Joshua Spacht
“A Love Story,” by Wicked Cinema
“Boo!” by Dresden the Flamingo
“Shifter,” by Wicked Cinema
“Ballroom Haunt,” by Dresden the Flamingo
“Reverence,” by Marie
“Molokai,” by Ian Kelosky
“Curiosity,” by Shimmer
“Grit,” by Wastelander
Outro: “Left for Dead,” by Wastelander

Discussion about this episode

User's avatar